• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Créme de la Créme Bakery & Cafe

Créme de la Créme Bakery & Cafe is a charming oasis nestled in Columbus, Ohio. This delightful bakery and café offers a warm ambiance and a diverse menu, perfect for groups and individuals looking to indulge in sweet and savory delights. From artisanal pastries to light lunch options, each dish is crafted with care and packed with flavor. Their inviting outdoor seating is dog-friendly, and the commitment to sustainability is evident with compostable containers and reusable tableware. With a variety of exquisite teas and innovative flavor combinations, every visit promises to be a memorable experience for food lovers and casual diners alike.

Créme de la Créme Bakery & Cafe: Reviews & Ratings

Mark K.
Mark K.

I've been meaning to get over here, and I keep hearing how good it is. I'm just not over this way often. But I was passing by and hungry today. It is worth the hype. It's a little café in a strip mall by Walmart. But it is beautiful and soothing inside. You can get good coffee. You can get amazing pastries. And you can get a light lunch. I got a little bit of each. I certainly would've gotten more pastries if I didn't already have sweets at home. I got the chebureky because I had never had them before and they sounded good. Very thin pockets of thin pastry wrapping ground meat. Excellent. They come with a creamy dipping sauce. I also got a Napoleon because I used to love those. And this one was excellent. Thin layers of sweet pastry, and a sweet, but not overly rich cream in between. The latte was huge and flavorful and had a nice design on top. Service is minimal but fast and friendly. Prices are decent. Well worth a detour.

Karin K.
Karin K.

Service was very Attentive and Helpful. Ambiance is beautiful. Very Clean. Food is Fresh, flavorful and its presentation is enticing. Definitely will return.

Aubrie H.
Aubrie H.

Another day another amazing visit. This time we tried the crapes. Cooked perfectly with beautiful fresh fruit on top. As always I had to grab the vegan danish on my way out, it's my absolute favorite!

Kelly A.
Kelly A.

The Rose tea was delicious! And also the tea set that your tea comes in makes you feel like royalty. The pastries are absolutely delightful my favorite pastry is the one that looks like roses and the filling has this passion fruit curd that was so delicious and not overly sweet which I enjoy. Definitely go to try this place.

Marie B.
Marie B.

I visited here a few months ago when they had just opened. It was clear they were a hot new place as it was pretty much impossible to get a table even though they had a good number of them. The case was a also a little light in some areas as it was a busy Saturday. I tried a few pastries/desserts and really enjoyed them all. The star of my visit though was the hot tea I tried. I think it was called 1001 Nights and was a very unique tasting blend. My friend got a cappuccino and said it was delicious as well. I would be happy to return here next time I'm in Hilliard!

Lori Q.
Lori Q.

I stopped by on a whim for a caffeine pick me up on the drive home and it was such a pleasant surprise. I got a pistachio flat white And it tasted great. The place is clean, lots of seating inside and out, and I especially loved the decor. The 2 Bathrooms were also clean. What is most impressive is the service. The two ladies at manning the front were the sweetest and approachable and answered any questions. They were eager to help. I also got the pistachio eclair and pistachio cheesecake and they both tasted good. I'll definitely be back to try more pastries and cake. They have sandwiches, too. I didn't try one and I'm impressed with their variety. When I'm in Hilliard, I'd easily stop by for another drink and treat.

Eve R.
Eve R.

Such a cute cafe found in sort of an unattractive strip mall. Don't let that deter you! The staff is friendly and the food is delicious. Proportions are what it would consider European and the prices are fair (all things considered...it's a bit spendy). We tried a couple sandwiches (breakfast croissant and prosciutto sammy) and both were great. The pistachio cake was nice, but I think I'd try something else as a sweet treat next time.

Joe F.
Joe F.

My friend and I visited this bakery on a Saturday afternoon. We were both excited to try it after seeing posts on social media. Créme de la Créme was busy when we arrived. Most of the indoor tables were full. The line moved pretty fast. While waiting we were able to decide on which desserts we wanted. There are two cases displaying all of the beautiful items. I ordered a vanilla latte and a few dessert items. The latte was delicious with a nice blend of coffee, almond milk and vanilla. The espresso and chocolate caramel macarons were also good. The best item I tried was the honey cake. The cake and cream cheese frosting were a perfect pairing. They have some savory options, but on this visit I didn't try those items. I will try on my next visit.

Location

Welcome to Créme de la Créme Bakery & Cafe, a hidden gem nestled in the vibrant strip mall near Walmart at 5311 Westpointe Plaza Drive, Columbus, OH 43228. This delightful café is not just a bakery; it's a culinary oasis where indulgence and flavor take center stage.

As you step inside, you're greeted by a soothing ambiance that invites you to unwind. The chic decor and clean environment reflect a careful attention to detail, making it a perfect spot for groups, a cozy outing with loved ones, or even a serene moment to yourself. The noise level strikes a comfortable balance, allowing for pleasant conversations while enjoying your treats.

One highlight of Créme de la Créme is its commitment to sustainability, offering compostable containers and reusable tableware. Additionally, it's great that the café is dog-friendly and equipped with gender-neutral restrooms and Wi-Fi, catering to the modern diner.

  • Diverse Beverage Selection: Experience an extensive tea menu featuring exotic blends like 1001 Nights, Royal Dessert, and Cleopatra's Night. Coffee enthusiasts will appreciate the expertly crafted lattes and cappuccinos.
  • Decadent Pastries: Treat yourself to a variety of pastries, including the stunning rose-shaped pastry filled with passion fruit curd—a favorite among patrons.
  • Light Lunch Offerings: Relish in flavorful options like the chebureky, a delightful pastry filled with ground meat, accompanied by a creamy dipping sauce. The menu also includes well-prepared crepes topped with fresh fruit.

Customer experiences testify to the charm of this café. From the attentive service to the vibrant décor, each visit promises a new adventure in flavor. Mark K. describes perfect pastries alongside delicious coffee, while Karin K. notes the freshness and inviting presentation of their dishes.

Créme de la Créme Bakery & Cafe is more than just a place to grab a quick bite—it's a destination for food lovers, tea enthusiasts, and anyone looking to treat themselves to something special. Whether it's a sweet pastry or a fragrant cup of tea, each visit affirms that this establishment is indeed worthy of its name. Don't miss the opportunity to indulge—stop by and savor the delightful offerings that await!